Except for Lyra. Lyra ALWAYS surprises us.
They bumped into Ally'esch'ya again during last weeks session, rescuing her and her ship-wrecked entourage from a passel of bugbears and dire wolves led by an Ogre barbarian. The PCs' reactions were pretty much the same as they were the first time around...including Lyra's.
As a straight-laced and pretty conventional DM, I sense difficult, possibly squirm-inducing, times ahead.